
Caravaggi et al. Journal of Foot and Ankle Research (2015) 8:59 DOI 10.1186/s13047-015-0116-3 JOURNAL OF FOOT AND ANKLE RESEARCH Open Access Pedobarographic and kinematic analysis in the functional evaluation of two post-operative forefoot offloading shoes Paolo Caravaggi*, Alessia Giangrande, Lisa Berti, Giada Lullini and Alberto Leardini Abstract Background: Forefoot offloading shoes are special orthopaedic footwear designed to protect and unload the injured part of the foot after surgery and for conservative treatments. The offloading action is often achieved by transferring plantar load to the rearfoot via rocker shoes with reduced contact area between shoe and ground. While these shoes are intended to be worn only for short periods, a compromise must be found between functionality and the risk of alterations in gait patterns at the lower limb joints. In this study, the pedobarographic, kinematic and kinetic effects of a traditional half-shoe and a double-rocker full-outsole shoe were compared to those of a comfortable shoe (control). Methods: Ten healthy female participants (28.2 ± 10.0 years) were asked to walk in three different footwear conditions for the left/right foot: control/half-shoe, control/full-outsole, and control/control. Full gait analysis was obtained in three walking trials for each participant in each condition. Simultaneously a sensor insole system recorded plantar pressure in different foot regions. Normalized root-mean-square error, coefficient of determination, and frame-by-frame statistical analysis were used to assess differences in time-histories of kinematic and kinetic parameters between shoes. Results: The half -shoe group showed the slowest walking speed and the shortest stride length. Forefoot plantar load was significantly reduced in the half-shoe (maximum force as % of Body Weight: half-shoe = 62.1; full-outsole = 86.9; control = 93.5; p < 0.001). At the rearfoot, mean pressure was the highest in the full-outsole shoe. At the ankle, sagittal-plane kinematics in the full-outsole shoe had a pattern more similar to control. Conclusions: The half-shoe appears significantly more effective in reducing plantar load at the forefoot than a double-rocker full-outsole shoe, which is designed to reduce forefoot loading by using an insole with a thicker profile anteriorly as to maintain the foot in slight dorsiflexion. However, the half-shoe is also associated with altered gait spatio-temporal parameters, more kinematic modifications at the proximal lower limb joints and reduced propulsion in late stance. Keywords: Offloading shoes, Kinematics, Kinetics, Plantar pressure, Lower limb joints Background The use of specific orthopaedic shoes is often recommended for foot conservative treatments and after surgery. Patients are required to wear forefoot offloading shoes (FOS) following several types of forefoot interventions, such as the surgical correction of hallux valgus and of lesser toe deformities, and in the treatment of * Correspondence: [email protected] Movement Analysis Laboratory and Functional-Clinical Evaluation of Prostheses, Istituto Ortopedico Rizzoli, Via di Barbiano 1/10, 40136 Bologna, Italy plantar ulcers in the diabetic foot [1–3]. FOS are intended to protect and unload the injured part of the foot via a large variety of designs [4–6]. One of the most traditional and widely-used FOS design, known as halfshoe - “talus-shoe” and “reverse camber” are other less common definitions [7] - features a low-profile outsole in the forefoot region. The half-shoe has been shown to be highly effective in reducing forefoot pressure in gait; however, due to its peculiar design, this FOS is liable to discomfort and instability [8–12]. © 2015 Caravaggi et al. Open Access This article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons license, and indicate if changes were made. The Creative Commons Public Domain Dedication waiver (http://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/) applies to the data made available in this article, unless othe
Open the catalog to page 1Caravaggi et al. Journal of Foot and Ankle Research (2015) 8:59 While several shoe designs for forefoot offloading have been proposed to address these issues, only few have been assessed thoroughly by established functional analysis before being introduced in the market. A FOS featuring a short-outsole design has proved to be extremely effective in reducing forefoot pressure when compared to the half-shoe, in either appropriate and inappropriate use – i.e. while attempting to put weight on the forefoot [8]. However the participants recruited in the study reported a more comfortable walk when...
Open the catalog to page 2Caravaggi et al. Journal of Foot and Ankle Research (2015) 8:59 Fig. 1 Region-based temporal profiles of peak pressure. Left, time-histories of peak pressure (kPa) for each shoe condition at rearfoot, midfoot, forefoot and total foot. Temporal patterns are shown as mean values and standard deviation bands. Right, the three shoes tested in the study (top to bottom): a traditional half-shoe, the full-outsole shoe and the control shoe each shoe configuration, for a total of 30 samples in each shoe group across the ten participants. These were recorded, together with the ground reaction forces and...
Open the catalog to page 3Caravaggi et al. Journal of Foot and Ankle Research (2015) 8:59 Mean and peak pressure Spatio-temporal parameters and ground reaction force Both FOS showed differences in peak pressure profiles with respect to control, although the full-outsole shoe showed values more similar to the control (Fig. 1, Additional file 2: Figure S1). In the half-shoe, mean and peak pressure were lower than control at forefoot (Fig. 2). The full-outsole shoe showed the largest mean pressure in the rearfoot (kPa, half-shoe = 102.9 (p = 0.021); fulloutsole = 120.3 (p = 0.044); control = 101.1). The half-shoe showed...
Open the catalog to page 42 Pages